LEGAL DISCLAIMER
I am not a Tax Lawyer, Nor do I play Dan Evans on the internet.
I am not a Certified Public Accountant, Nor do I play Paul Thomas on the internet.
I am not an Enrolled Agent, Nor do I play Richard Macdonald on the internet.
DO NOT TAKE MY WORD FOR ANYTHING ON THIS PAGE.
Go look it up for yourself.

U.S. Federal Income Tax

Mr. Macdonald's arguments:

Table of Contents

Post 1                    Post 8                    Post 15               
Post 2                    Post 9                    Post 16               
Post 3                    Post 10                  Post 17               
Post 4                    Post 11                  Post 18               
Post 5                    Post 12                  Post 19               
Post 6                    Post 13                  Post 20                
Post 7                    Post 14                  Post 21                 

 misc.taxes


Of course Dale will insist that the Constitution says things that he cannot cite in the document and then denies the powers of Congress clearly styated in the Constution and properly cited.

Q1. Is the Constitution the source of ALL authority of any Federal Level governmental action, power, or duty?

Google Archive

> Q1. Is the Constitution the source of ALL authority of any Federal Level governmental action, power, or duty?

Yes.

Now as to the Constitution, here is a clear Constitutional question that you are running from answering like a whipped cur and I will NOT address any of your other questions until it is answered:

Under Article I, Section 8 and Article III, Section 1, of the US Constitution, Congress has the power to establish courts lesser than the Supreme Court. True or False.

Google Archive

> ... I will NOT address any of your other questions until it is answered:

> Under Article I, Section 8 and Article III, Section 1, of the US Constitution, Congress has the power to establish courts lesser than the Supreme Court. True or False.

Google Archive

Here's your answer:  In Your VERY OWN WORDS:

SPECIFIC QUESTION: Mr. Macdonald, is the IRS required to follow precedent of the Executive Hearing Board of Tax Appeals decisions, er Tax Court decisions?

The IRS is not required to follow ANY Court decision below that of the Supreme Court.

Then neither am I.

So having admitted that the tax court is meaningless, are you going to continue posting tax court crap?

Your following question is void for irrelevance.  Tax Court does not apply to me, therefore what tax court is, is irrelevant.

Dale seems to be quite afraid to answer this question: Under Article I, Section 8 and Article III, Section 1, of the US Constitution Congress has the power to establish courts lesser than the Supreme Court.
True or False.

Ten.  The answer is ten. That's how many angels I think can dance on the head of a pin today.

You are a piss poor chess player.  I have no problem sacrificing a queen if it leads to my checkmating my opponent.  While you are thumping your chest over what you think is a significant move on your part, arguing about whether the Board of Tax Appeals, er Tax Court is a real court or not, (crowing about capturing my queen) you haven't bothered to notice the checkmate. 

By your very own words, it does not matter. (Checkmate.)

QUOTE:
"The IRS is not required to follow ANY Court decision below that of the Supreme Court." END QUOTE

Google Archive

Q2. Was a purpose of the Constitution because under the Articles of Confederation, the Federal Government was "embarrassed" when the States didn't meet their quota's of funds for support of the Federal government?

In other words, was a purpose of the Constitution to give Congress the power to secure funds for the purpose of operating the Federal government that was not included in the Articles of Confederation?
Mr. Macdonald has refused to answer the question.

The answer is yes. 

One of the reasons for the Constitution was because the Articles of Confederation gave absolutely NO power to the "federal" government to directly tax the people.











Table of Contents